top of page
< Back

Ashley Rose Young

Listen Now
Interview with Celebrated Historian, Curator & Author, Ashley Rose YoungEat My Globe by Simon Majumdar
00:00 / 01:04

Ashley Rose Young Interview

On this episode of Eat My Globe, our host, Simon Majumdar, talks to Ashley Rose Young, the celebrated author of “Nourishing Networks: The Public Culture of Food in New Orleans,” where they discuss the history of public markets, street vending, and modern markets. They also discuss her role as a historian and curator at the Library of Congress, and more. It’s an informative and entertaining conversation you do not want to miss.

Support Eat My Globe on Patreon:
Share This Page on Social Media:
Transcript

Eat My Globe

Dr. Ashley Rose Young Interview

 

Simon Majumdar (“SM:”)

Welcome to a brand new episode of Eat My Globe, a podcast about things you didn't know you didn't know about food. Ashley Rose is a very special guest, a curator and public historian whose research and writing have appeared in the New York Times, the Washington Post and other outlets. She is the author of this terrific new book, “Nourishing Networks: The Public Culture of Food in New Orleans,” which is published by Oxford University Press, which we will be talking about today. Dr. Young serves as an American history curator in the Rare Books and Special Collections Division at the Library of Congress. I want that job. She's also a Smithsonian research associate and was formerly the historian of the Smithsonian Food History Project at the National Museum of American History, which I think is where I first met you. Dr. Young grew up working alongside her mother, aunts, siblings and cousins at their Pittsburgh-based family business, McGuinness Sisters Special Food Stores. It gives me the greatest pleasure to introduce you to Ashley Young. How are you, Ashley? Well, it's so good to have you on Eat My Globe. We've had so many people from the Smithsonian and others and it's so good to have you.

 

Ashley Rose Young (“ARY”):

It's wonderful to be here, Simon. And I was actually looking back through my email to see when first we came in contact with each other. And it was for the 2017 Smithsonian Food History Weekend. And you were on a panel. I believe you were moderating conversations on this panel with other culinary and food history experts and food culture experts. And I was looking back through our, our planning emails about how the moderated panel would go and all of that. And we also had a chance not too long after that to do a live cooking demonstration together.

 

SM:

Yes.

 

ARY:

I think you made your Life Saving Dal. And I remember being totally captivated and enamored by your story and your resilience and how food can save lives as well as nurture our bodies.

 

SM:

I remember that I know you're gonna be talking to us about food and public culture and in one of my favourite cities in the world. And it tells you it's one of my favorite eating cities anywhere, through your new book, “Nourishing Networks: The Public Culture of Food in New Orleans.” However, before we start doing that, I'd love to know what you're going to, what you're doing next. I mean you sound like your job's fairly busy right now. But tell me a bit more about what you're going to do now.

 

ARY:

Yes, so I'm in a new role at the Library of Congress. Like you mentioned, I'm an American history curator in the Rare Book Division. And that is a fantastic place to be. We have some of the most wonderful historic cookbooks, dating back to the 1500s, the 1600s, and through the present day in the Rare Book Division. And I walk through our stacks where these books are housed and I think to myself, I can't believe this is my daily life. And I get to just be with these amazing objects, these amazing books all of the time.

 

SM:

I'm so jealous because that's my yeah, and I'm not saying I want to come and steal your job, but I think that's a great thing to have and I just I. . .

 

ARY:

And when you're next in DC, you'll have to come hang out with me at the library and we can look at some of those books together. And I really kind of offer this to anyone, including your listeners, get in touch with me. If you want to, coordinate a fun experience looking at some historic rare books together, you know, you can reach me at my website. There's contact info at AshleyRoseYoung.com. And I'm serious about that. So don't be shy.

 

SM:

Well we'll definitely have some people because we have a lot of listeners and they all want to talk about that sort of thing and come and do them.

 

But before we talk about that again, we'll talk about it at the end. What made New Orleans your choice? Because I love it, as I mentioned, I love its culture, I love everything about it. is there something about the city that made it special for you? Was this just your own love of the city coming from I think you're in Southern Beverage, a food and beverage museum, weren't you?

 

ARY:

I was, but I think my love of the city started long before then, and really because I chose to study French in middle school as my, foreign language, and it was very common in Pittsburgh, far, far away from. . .

 

SM:

Yeah.

 

ARY:

. . . New Orleans. You know, I was in the Appalachian Mountains in a, historically steel town that was in a rust belt area of the United States, so far away from the Gulf Coast.

 

But I would learn about Mardi Gras. Every February or March in French class, we would celebrate Mardi Gras. I would just imagine myself as a young girl, 12 or 13 years old, imagining myself going down to New Orleans. I used to, and I don't even know how I did this in Pittsburgh, but I have memories of watching the Mardi Gras Day Parade on cable TV from my home in Pittsburgh, just dreaming of setting foot in the city one day. But that opportunity wouldn't arise till I was in college. And I finally, after playing for the Yale women's golf team for several years, I had chosen to step away from the sport and I finally had a free summer. And I thought, ooh, what can I do? What can I do with my first free summer between my junior and senior year of college? And when I went to the internship database at the Yale kind of Professional Development Center, the very first entry on the list was for an internship at the Southern Food and Beverage Museum in New Orleans. And, I reached out to Liz Williams, the founder of the museum, and I said, Hey, Liz, you know, I'm Ashley. I'm. . .  I've always wanted to have an internship or come to New Orleans. I'm really interested in food history, my family's in food. Is there any way I could apply for this internship. And by the way, I would have to start a month late, later than you'd want me to. And Liz, who is now a dear, dear friend and my longtime mentor, said yes. And her response changed the trajectory of my life. I went. . .

 

SM:

Which is. . .

 

ARY:

. . . to New Orleans. Liz introduced me to New Orleans food culture, Creole food culture, and the food culture of the South to be honest. And. . .

 

SM:

Yeah.

 

ARY:

. . . I just said, I, I just want to keep studying this. I want to write my senior history thesis about it. And I made the crazy decision to go straight into a master's PhD program to keep writing about and researching the history of New Orleans. But I stepped foot in that city and honestly, within 24 hours, I felt that I'd found my true love. If your true love can be a place, rather than a person at, twenty years old.

 

SM:

Whenever I follow that. . . . first of all, your town, Pittsburgh, is the sister of my town in England, Sheffield, or Sheffield and Rotherham. And that's because Sheffield is a steel town as well. So that's the thing I want to say. So, I know Pittsburgh and actually they have some great food there. But I have your same feeling about New Orleans because I know so many of the people there and everywhere you go, you go to various different spaces, whether it's from having the beignets to going through all these fabulous restaurants to anywhere, go fried chicken at Co ops or whatever, and it's all so special. But before you tell us about that, I think it's probably better because not a lot of people will know what food's public culture actually means. and sometimes even I'm like, Well what does it mean?

 

ARY:

That's a great question. And I think that's the part of the book that is grounded in my academic research. We come up with these terms to try to define a new concept or a new way of looking at the culture of a place. And so that's a little bit of the academic shining through. Although I'm sure, as you saw in the book as well, there's very descriptive and evocative. . .

 

SM:

Yep.

 

ARY:

. . . language, and so it's kind of this crossover book as well for the public who are interested in history and kind of willing to dip their toe into some academic aspects, but it's also I think an interesting read for your just everyday food culture lover. But. . .

 

SM:

Yeah, it really is.

 

ARY:

. . . but let's get to public culture. And so, as I was kind of growing up again in my 20s, I had the opportunity to travel the globe pretty extensively. Believe it or not, with my a cappella group, my college a cappella group of all things is what took me around the world right after graduation. And as we were in Asia and South Asia, in the Middle East, in Africa, and in Europe, I noticed that so many cultures, so many countries that I went to had these spaces outdoors that were basically farmers markets or public market places that might have been covered, but you could still easily walk in and out of them. And as I was, and I think a lot of people who travel globally will often try to find the local market exactly.

 

SM:

Oh yeah, that's what I do whenever I'm travelling.

 

ARY:

That's how you get to know a place. You first get to like taste the difference of a place, right? And then. . .

 

SM:

Yeah.

 

ARY:

. . . you kind of move beyond that to the, I don't know, music culture or the museums or whatnot. And so, as I was traveling around, I kept thinking these markets are so stunning and wonderful and full of life. Did the United States ever have public markets or street markets like this? And something that's different than the kind of modern farmers market that we have, right? I grew up in the 90s and 2000s. We had farmers markets, once a week in most major cities. But I'm talking about every day you are going to the market, you are getting your fresh food, it's happening in the city streets, it's happening outdoors. what is the history of that, if there is one, in the United States? And so that's what got me thinking about the quote unquote public culture of food in New Orleans. As I started studying the city, I started seeing descriptions of street vendors in the 1800s, who would be roaming the city streets, crying out about the amazing fresh wares, the fresh produce and prepared foods that were available to passers-by. I was coming across city records about these city-operated public markets that were accessible to the street, they were open air, except for a very basic pavilion that would protect vendor stalls from rain and wind. Things like that. But there was so much happening in this local food culture, this local food economy, in the city streets, in the parks, in these open-air markets. And to me, that is a part of New Orleans history that had largely been overlooked because we're so fascinated with its restaurant culture. I mean, New Orleans restaurants loom very large in the American imagination.

 

SM:

Yes. yes.

 

ARY:

But I was thinking, what about the everyday people who were like actually just buying food to prepare at home or to eat in the streets? And so that's where public culture of food comes from. It's specifically the like exchange and consumption of food on sidewalks, in city streets, in the parks, and in these public open-air markets. That's public. . .

 

SM:

And I. . .

 

ARY:

. . . culture.

 

SM:

. . . and I love that because recently I was actually travelling the ‘Stans, not Afghanistan, Kazakhstan, all of those. And what we did when we went. . . went to six of them, I think, and when you went into each one, the first thing you did is to go to the market because that's where you see people, that's where you see shopping and selling. And that everywhere you go in the world, and you start though by in about the eighteen hundreds, don't you? And you start by telling us that and this is quoting from you, Black vendors who were the principal food retailers in antebellum, New Orleans. So, I'd like to know why and why you say some of this was I think you say imbued with the women before enslavement. And I'd like to know how that happens as well.

 

ARY:

Yeah. Absolutely. So, if you're studying New Orleans, you have to study the history of the city within the context of the transatlantic slave trade. New Orleans would not have grown to the city that it is without its very complicated history with the transatlantic slave trade, as it was the largest port for enslaved people to forcibly be moved into as they were coming into the United States. So, it is a centerpiece of this very problematic and complex history that we have with slavery in this country. But many of the individuals who were forcibly brought from West Africa were from the Senegambia region, where the Gambia River is in West. . .

 

SM:

Yep.

 

ARY:

. . .Africa. And these are communities where it was very common for women in particular to be the head of marketing in their community, who would be out with carrying fresh produce on their heads in baskets, or operating informal stands or areas and selling goods. This was very common. It was a woman-dominated retail economy, so to speak, in West Africa. And as those women had been enforcibly enslaved and brought to the United States, or what would become the United States, actually, it was colonial. A colonial French entity. . .

 

SM:

Of course.

 

ARY:

. . .and then a colonial Spanish entity, New Orleans was for a while. But these women actually resumed those roles, even as enslaved people in New Orleans. And you might be wondering: well, how does that work? If they’re enslaved people, aren’t they working in the fields? What’s happening with the plantation? And you have to keep in mind that New Orleans had a very particular kind of plantation economy. And these plantations were much smaller compared to the ones that you had in the Carolinas or even Georgia.

 

SM:

Uh-huh.

 

ARY:

They were much closer to the city of New Orleans than those others I was mentioning. And so, there was a lot of movement, believe it or not, between enslaved people on plantations and people in the city center, quote unquote, city of New Orleans. It was a very small colonial outcropping for decades and decades and decades till you get to the antebellum period. But, these were kind of, small-scale operations and enslavers really didn’t have the means to actually feed the enslaved population that they were making work on their plantations. And so, there was this kind of culture that developed that French enslavers, German enslavers, they would give a piece of their land to the enslaved people to cultivate food for their own consumption. So that enslaved people were responsible for growing corns and bean and squash. . .

 

SM:

Yeah.

 

ARY:

. . .and other foods, raising fowl, hunting deer, hunting bear, and feeding themselves. And they would sometimes grow extra produce. And so, it was very common, especially on Sundays, for enslaved people to migrate into the city center and set up stalls for other enslaved people to purchase from them. Other city dwellers to purchase this extra produce. And there was a loophole in colonial French law that enabled these enslaved people to actually accrue money, to actually take profit from what they were selling.

 

SM:

That's interesting.

 

ARY:

It's very interesting. It's not the same in the different colonial entities that would become part of the United States, but in Louisiana, the Code Noir or the Black Code had this loophole in it. And it kind of just became, that just became the norm. And enslavers also employed enslaved women who already had this ability to sell wares like they did in West Africa. They tasked those women to take produce from the larger plantation and sell it in the city center as well. So those enslaved vendors would be selling on behalf of their enslaver. But again, they were often permitted to take a small percentage of the sales and keep that for themselves. So, you actually see in New Orleans through various means enslaved people actually saving enough money over decades of labor to actually purchase their own freedom or the freedom of their family members. And New Orleans had a very significant population of free people of color. Not solely through the marketing, but marketing enabled a surprising number of people to transition from being enslaved to actually being free persons. And that's not necessarily the case, or at least in any significant number, in other cities along the eastern seaboard. So, you have this exceptional space and this exceptional history in New Orleans.

 

SM:

So, let's talk about that because I know I've been to Senegal and I've been to those areas and I've seen the women in the markets carrying so much stuff and it's an amazing sight. So, what, what kind of foods were they selling in the markets? I mean were they selling West African or the equivalent of West African because they didn't get all the ingredients, or were they serving some of the Creole stuff that was coming? Because that's one of the things that I'm just fascinated by.

 

ARY:

So, you have a mixture. And New Orleans being a port city, like any port city, really, you're gonna have a confluence of different migratory groups and their cultures coming together in one place. So, you're not gonna have purely West African food, you're not gonna have purely French or Spanish or even parts of the Caribbean. There's going to be this kind of mélange.

 

But in the early 1800s, you'll have travel writers coming to New Orleans and they're talking about the enslaved African women sitting on the side of the market ways and having steaming bowls of gumbo available for purchase. And they'll have these kind of pyramidal piles of rice next to them, and they were serving rice and gumbo together. And gumbo, God help you if you try to define that by any set number of ingredients, but it's a soup or stew. And in New Orleans, it often includes fresh seafood, local fowl, waterfowl. It might include pork products like andouille sausage, or a combination thereof. Often it includes okra, directly brought from the West African tradition of okra stews, although it doesn't necessarily have to have okra. There'll be people who will fight you tooth and nail on that, but with whatever yeah.

 

SM:

Yes, I know. I've had some of those conversations on Eat My Globe as well.

 

ARY:

Yes, yes.

 

SM:

Gumbo for me is something that almost symbolizes New Orleans to me anyway. But let's, let's talk about the freed peoples because you mentioned that earlier, but could you tell me a little bit about how that all happened because I really found that interesting that they helped get themselves free by marketing.

 

ARY:

Yes, so I kind of make the point in the book that some women, one fried rice fritter at a time, one Calas at a time, or one cup of Creole coffee at a time, or one praline at a time, a sugary pecan candy, were. . .

 

SM:

Yeah.

 

ARY:

. . . able to slowly, so slowly, save enough money again to self-manumit, as we say in academia, or to purchase their own freedom. But there were many ways that individuals might acquire freedom. There were interesting relationships that happened in New Orleans where French descent men, for example, would take on mistresses, some of whom were enslaved, some of whom were free women of color, that would kind of manage. . .

 

SM:

Yeah.

 

ARY:

. . . their business for them. This was a practice called plaçage. And it's a very complex relationship because you have Black women in relationships with white men, the power dynamic is never going to be equal in that situation in the antebellum south. But to the extent that they could, Black women were using those relationships to their advantage and for their children who were of mixed race. And. . .

 

SM:

Yeah.

 

ARY:

. . . so there was often instances in which French descent or Spanish descent men would actually free their children, to free the children that have what might have been born into slavery within this kind of system of plaçage, or if they were born to a free woman of color, then they would not have been born into slavery per se. So that kind of created this generational freedom, but something. . .

 

SM:

Yeah.

 

ARY:

. . . to keep in mind is that that freedom was always tenuous. There was always a chance, especially if free people of color were moving throughout the state or traveling other places that they could be re-enslaved or enslaved for the first time if they were born free. So, I don't want people to think these individuals were living an amazing life as free people of color. It was very specifically within a context in which they were by no means equal to free whites, but certainly had more access to wealth and, and certain rights than enslaved African people and their enslaved descendants. So, it was kind of a tripartite system, caste system in New Orleans.

 

SM:

That's interesting. Talking of the travelers who came in, one of the people I like reading about was Frederica Bremer. I hope I've got that right. And this one thing that she declared and it's how I feel about New Orleans and about other places. She said one of the most lively and picturesque scenes in New Orleans was the market. So, she didn't see these? So she didn't see these in other places? What was it about New Orleans? What was it about the people that really came to her? Because you said lots of travellers came into this area.

 

ARY:

I think the travelers are key. So, there was a lot of movement of people into the city of New Orleans. Cause New Orleans sat at the, the base of the Mississippi River, the delta of the Mississippi River, and it was the way out into the Gulf, into the Caribbean. So, you had people from out the Atlantic world coming into this city. You had Europeans, you had people from the Caribbean, from Latin America, people coming down the Mississippi into the port of New Orleans and meeting in this one central retail and wholesale place that was the central French market as we know it today. And so, people talk about seeing, exotic birds from Latin America being sold at the French market. I read about a family of free Blacks who raised pelicans and other birds that they would bring to the French market to sell for whatever reason, either consumption or perhaps as lawn ornaments. I don't know. But there's this vibrancy, a chaotic sort of symphony of people and sounds and haggling and conversation. And I think because there was such a substantial role for enslaved African women and for free women of color, that kind of struck visitors as odd or unique or as something to remark upon. And visitors even likened the French market to Le Halles in Paris, the central marketplace in Paris, where it's as if every language on earth is being spoken in this one place. And I think that is the kind of romanticized descriptive version of the antebellum French market or even the French market in the second half of the 19th century. But it's also, you know, you have to keep in mind that mere blocks away, the slave market, the. . .

 

SM:

Yes.

 

ARY:

. . . slave market was located a few blocks away from where all of this food and all these exotic animals were exchanging hands. And you had people who were put onto the slave block and sold. You had families broken apart. And I am really struck by the idea of these street vendors who might have set up shop in what we now know as Jackson Square selling pralines or something else. And they literally can see the building in which they were sold into slavery, in which their family was sold into different areas of the United States. And we have examples of street vendors who went through that.

 

And so, there's this really discordant image of like, wow, this is such a beautiful, interesting market full of the richest elements of life, but it has an incredibly dark underbelly. And it's not even an underbelly because it's so visible.

 

SM:

Yeah. It's there.

 

ARY:

Yeah, it's there. So, it's the challenge of studying the place because at times I feel like I could get caught up in these really beautiful descriptions of the pyramids of fresh melons and the. . .

 

SM:

Yep.

 

ARY:

. . . the displays of citrus but those travel writers are very rarely in the same breath or same paragraphs talking about the slave market. So, it's like I said very discordant.

 

SM:

Now what I'm trying to do here is to get people interested, in seeing your books. So, I love reading about the crail, the vending cries that you used to get. I'd love to know who came up with these or were they from West Africa or wherever? And do you have an example of one?

 

ARY:

I love the street vendor cries, and they're one of the things that really drew me to studying street vendors because it was very common in the 1800s and early 1900s for writers to try to transcribe the street vendor cries that they were hearing on to the pages of their books. And sometimes they would do this without musical notation, they would just try to use like capital letters and dashes and things to kind of give you a sense of how a street vendor might emphasize a certain part of a word. But you actually had some kind of ethnographic writers, right? These anthropologists or proto-anthro-anthropologists going down and trying to transcribe these very melodic musical street cries on-to-sheet music that they then published. . .

 

SM:

Wow.

 

ARY:

. . . in their books and in cookbooks and you know in other ways. And so of course there were street vendors who were probably just literally yelling about what they. . .

 

SM:

Ha ha ha.

 

ARY:

. . . were selling. Not melodic, might have had screeching voices, but there was actually a strong musical tradition in West Africa, a strong musical tradition. . .

 

SM:

Yes.

 

ARY:

. . . in Europe, because we have floods of European immigrants coming into New Orleans in the 1840s and onward. And you have all of these musical cultures kind of clashing together in New Orleans. So, you have Black women singing in Creole. Many of those individuals might have been descended from Haitian revolution refugees who came en masse to the city around 1810 or so, kind of reinfusing the city with this Francophone and French culture from colonial Saint Domingue or Haiti. And then you also have the West African traditions and then the Italian traditions. If you fast forward 70 years. It's crazy.

 

SM:

Wow getting all getting all that together. So, since you're an a cappella person could. . .

 

ARY:

I am.

 

SM:

. . . is there some something you could. . . this is me kind of going is there something you could sing?

 

ARY:

Yes, I love singing the street cries.

 

SM:

I love this.

 

ARY:

These are street cries that were preserved by someone at the Smithsonian Folk Life Center, actually, Adelaide Van Wey, who worked with anthropologists to preserve the historic soundscape of New Orleans, and she saved some of the best cries. So, I will sing some of those for you.

 

SM:

Oh great.

 

ARY:

Now I'll sing two different ones. I'll start with horseradish because I love that one. And then I'll sing one about pralines. So, I'll start with horseradish.

 

SM:

Fantastic.

 

ARY:

Here we go. Let me clear my throat. Okay, so it goes something like this:

 

[Singing]

Horseradish. Horseradish. Good old tongue never lies. Grind your horseradish for your wives. Horseradish. Horseradish. Horseradish.

 

[Talking]

So that's an example of one. And a lot of these. . . .

 

SM:

That is beautiful.

 

ARY:

Yeah, it's beautiful, but there was a really strong musical tradition in New Orleans, and it makes sense that in the place where jazz was born, right? That you would. . .

 

SM:

Of course.

 

ARY:

. . . have this sort of like vernacular public soundscape as well. There's a lot of musical people in New Orleans. And then the other street cry I will share is for pralines, those sugary pecan treats.

 

SM:

Yeah, love those.

 

ARY:

They're so good. They're so sweet. And what I think's interesting about this particular street cry is that it is really melodic. It almost sounds like a lullaby. And I think that makes sense when you think about who the major customers were for the praline vendors in New Orleans. And that was children. It was kids in the park playing. They'd get a picayune, a cent or two, and go up to the praline vendor and buy a little sweet treat for themselves. So, you'll hear that this one is much softer and kind of soothing in a way. And it goes something like this.

 

[Singing]

Pralines. Pralines. For your sweet toothy. For your sweet toothy. Pralines.

 

[Talking]

I know, makes your heart ache.

 

SM:

It does make my heart ache because these are so beautiful, but so simple. Oh.

 

ARY:

Mm-hmm, exactly. And that's I mean, you'll hear these traditions not just in New Orleans but across the globe. Sicilian vendors, if you go to Sicily to this day, the. . .

 

SM:

Yeah.

 

ARY:

. . . street vendors there are singing out about the fresh produce and the pizza and the spleen sandwiches that they're selling.

 

SM:

I love the spleen sandwiches.

 

ARY:

Yeah.

 

SM:

Loc loco de anyway, down by the harbour.

 

ARY:

Exactly.

 

SM:

Stunning.

 

ARY:

And I would when I was there, I would say, can you sing some of your street vendor cries for me? And they would laugh and, and agree to it, which I appreciate.

 

And I even found that people were singing street cries, when I was in Cleveland, Ohio at the West Side Market, I was walking through this beautiful market. It was built, I think, in 1920 or maybe 1910 still operates as a proper food market to this day. And I was just walking through the produce aisle, where the produce vendors were, and I was wearing a Yale college t-shirt or sweatshirt, and one of the market vendors started improvising his cry about blackberries to say, Hey, Yaleys love blackberries too. Come on over here and get some blackberries. And I just had this moment of like, oh my god, this is happening to me.

 

SM:

This is all go, it's going on. In London. . .

 

ARY:

In real life, I know.

 

SM:

. . . you see people still singing about certain things in the markets.

 

But let's move on to this because after this period we begin to see it more systematic, didn't we? And so I'd love to talk about that, the people who ran the city at this point, they wanted to get them into kind of formal markets and. . .

 

ARY:

Yes.

 

SM:

. . . and so, I'd love to talk about that as well. And we've only got a few more questions, but I'd love to get taking it through to the convenience stores as well. So, tell us about. . .

 

ARY:

Yes, yes.

 

SM:

. . . the markets that they try to organise with kind of special rules.

 

ARY:

We will be leaving the antebellum period. But as I mentioned, the French market, it's the center of all marketing in New Orleans for decades. Basically, you know, around 1790 through around 1820 or so. But the city around 1820 is starting to grow exponentially. And this makes sense in the context of the Louisiana Purchase. It's no longer a French or Spanish entity. New Orleans and the larger Louisiana Territory become part of the United States within the first few years of the 19th century. And as that happens, you have all these Americans migrating down the East Coast into the Gulf and into New Orleans, and the city is exponentially growing and it's filling up with Yankees, God forbid. So, it. . .

 

SM:

Ha ha.

 

ARY:

. . . makes sense around 1820. The French Creoles, and the French Quarter are like, we've had enough of these Yankees, and the Yankees are like, we've had enough of you. We're gonna open up our own public market, and it's gonna rival what is in the French market.

 

SM:

Mm.

 

ARY:

We're gonna have our own space, St. Mary's Market. And then things keep growing. I mean, in the 1840s, 1830s, and 1840s, you start having German and Irish immigrants moving into that kind of now known as American sector, where those other Americans had settled. And the city keeps growing. And the city starts building more markets as the neighborhoods develop over time. And by 1840, New Orleans is essentially the second largest city in the United States. It's basically tied with Baltimore, and New York is number one at this point. So, one of the most important, if not the most important, port in the United States and one of the largest cities. How do you feed that population? New. . .

 

SM:

Yes.

 

ARY:

. . . Orleans essentially decided to model itself after Paris. This makes sense because of the long-standing connection to France and kind of the French Creole culture in the city. Go ahead.

 

SM:

Is could I just ask then, is this what the term model market came from?

 

ARY:

In a way, and I'll get to that in a second, but just imagine. . .

 

SM:

Okay.

 

ARY:

. . . with each new neighborhood that arises in New Orleans, they decide to build a market. And sometimes a developer would say, before we even drain this part of the swamp surrounding New Orleans, before we even start building homes or other businesses, let's build a market first, and everything else will come after that. So, you see that these little public markets in each neighborhood are actually the seed for development, for housing, for. . .

 

SM:

Oh.

 

ARY:

. . . other businesses. They literally become the like fodder of which New Orleans grows out of. It's. . .

 

SM:

That is fantastic.

 

ARY:

. . . amazing. And then after a while, you have so many markets, dozens and dozens at this point, that people say, all right, we gotta make these a little more standardized. We have to have some better regulation here. There are so many people living in this city. And that's where you have New Orleans city government saying, yes, like we've tried to regulate these markets in the past. We know we have to kind of up the ante here, especially as we become more aware of public health. And so, we're gonna make sure that you market vendors are selling fresh meat, that you're selling fresh produce, that you're not adulterating the foods. And this is kind of the parlance, so to speak, through the 1850s, 60s, 70s, 80s. I mean, we're going there. But you start to have a little bit of issue when the city government becomes more than a little bit corrupt. So, the market system. . .

 

SM:

Yes.

 

ARY:

. . . yeah, the market system worked beautifully for decades, but as it grew throughout the 19th century, it just started to break down. The city was not investing money back into the markets. And you had New Orleanians saying, Hey, I visited New York, I visited Savannah, I visited these other cities, and they have way better marketplaces than we do. They're built out of brick and stone, and they're substantial, they're enclosed, they have good ventilation, and we're kind of still out here in these little pavilion markets that are basically open to the street. What is going on? And so, imagine decades of fighting between vendors, customers, and the city government. And eventually around 1900, 1910, we get to this idea of model markets. And a model. . .

 

SM:

Okay.

 

ARY:

. . . market is a market that is either screened so that you don't have flies and other vermin coming in, or more and more it's enclosed. There's actual walls, so it's cut off from the street. It's also one that has great ventilation, that is being outfitted with electricity. And as refrigeration becomes more and more a technology, it's outfitted with refrigerated cases to keep food fresh. And that is the model market. And New Orleanians are looking at other cities, like I said, and going, they have these really nice facilities. We want that here too. Is that so much to ask that we can have like a modern facility? And they fight with the local government and the local government pushes back. But eventually, it's a decades-long process. Eventually. . .

 

SM:

Yeah. Ha ha.

 

ARY:

. . . in the 1930s, as part of the WPA, Alphabet Soup WPA, the city government works with the federal government to actually build these beautiful model markets in all of the neighborhoods in New Orleans. they bulldoze all the little pavilions and they put up, these small but really well-built markets that have refrigeration and electricity and beautiful stalls and they cater to the local neighborhood. They're not, just one giant space that the whole city goes to. It's a very unique little neighborhood thing. And they're beautiful, they're in Art Deco, they're in WPA modern, some have Spanish kind of influenced architecture, just really stunning buildings. And then they open to the public, it's very exciting, but then World War II hits, and essentially. . .

 

SM:

Oh okay. Yeah.

 

ARY:

. . . the market system completely collapses after World War II. It's like we just opened these beautiful buildings, America joins the war, and by nineteen forty-five or nineteen fifty, you don't have a single public market operating in New Orleans. And they had over thirty.

 

SM:

Oh wow.

 

ARY:

They had over thirty public markets. And by nineteen fifty, they're all just they're done. They're donezo.

 

SM:

Well let's talk about that. So, the fifties were probably forties and fifties was when the supermarket came in. And the supermarket, I think, apart from the odd bit of ingredients that they have from here and there but usually it's just the same everywhere in the country and it probably everywhere in the world primarily. And how did that affect New Orleans?

 

ARY:

Yes.

 

SM:

Because that was suddenly going from very West African and other type of ingredients going to biscuits and whatever.

 

ARY:

Yep. The meteoric rise of the supermarket, as they like to describe it, was the death knell of the public markets in New Orleans. And I have a fondness for the public markets because, like I said, they were built for specific neighborhoods. You knew who your vendors were, you knew who grew your produce. These were community centers that were bringing money back into the community because the people who lived there worked in the market or shopped at the market. But then you have the rise of the chain store. And this happened, starting in the 1910s and 1920s. You kind of have the glimmerings of these first chain markets like Piggly Wiggly and A&P, these kind of long-known names of supermarkets today, although not all of them exist in their, that historic iteration anymore.

 

SM:

Sure.

 

ARY:

But New Orleanians looked around, especially after World War II, and saw these kind of suburban communities developing on the outskirts of the city. This is car culture central. You had a middle class and wealthy white families in this mass exodus of urban city centers moving out to the suburbs. Kind of known in popular language as white flight, this period of white flight.

 

SM:

Yeah.

 

ARY:

And the people left in the city center were working poor, many were people of color. And basically, it became economically unviable to keep the public markets operating in the city, or even to run little mom and pop grocery stores. So, you have those businesses shutting down or moving their operations to the suburbs to take advantage of the money that had moved outside of the city centers and into these suburban communities and people raved about the convenience of giant supermarkets. I get to go shopping once a week I don't have to go every day I can go once a week have this giant shopping cart of ready-made meals canned foods my life is so easy so convenient and I'm gonna use my car and bring that all back to my suburban home. But I think we are dealing and have been dealing for a long time with the consequences of the rise of the supermarket and shelf stable foods and highly preserved foods. . .

 

SM:

Yes.

 

ARY:

. . . and the abandonment of urban communities and working poor communities in urban centers that we're still guessing at how to fix today.

 

SM:

And I want to talk to you about that in just a second, but first I just wanted to take into account where we are in New Orleans, of course. And there was one chap called Arthur Robinson who I read in the book, they say he was the last or one of the last, and he was given a second line and I love reading about that. I remember second lines when I go there, but some people might not know what that is. And he was given that by the city or by whoever.

 

ARY:

Yes, Arthur Robinson's story is so moving, and he I use his story to open the book and to conclude the book. So, it's kind of book-ended with his life story. And he was known as one of the last street vendors or the last street vendor in New Orleans, and he was a person who actually used a very beautifully, colorfully painted pickup truck to sell produce throughout the many and varied neighborhoods in New Orleans from historically Black neighborhoods to neighborhoods that surrounded that were historically wealthier and white up near Tulane University. He went all over the city and he would use this little microphone and cry out about what produce he had, but not in the melodic way that 1920s vendors would sing out. He would be like. . .

 

[Singing]

I got oranges and bananas, I got water melon too.

 

[Talking]

Just like very monotone. And they actually sold keychains in the local grocery store that had little buttons you could press and his street cry would be projected out of the little keychain. But anyway, he was in a monumental figure in New Orleans. People adored Arthur Robinson or Mr. Okra as he was known.

 

SM:

Ha ha.

 

ARY:

He brought smiles to people's faces. He was always had an appearance at Jazz Fest. I mean, everyone had t-shirts about him and they could all mimic his street cries. Everyone knew Mr. Okra. And when he passed away, as part of his funeral tradition, which is very traditional in New Orleans, they had a second line.

 

So, historically in New Orleans, when there's a funeral, there would actually be a procession of the casket through the city streets, and this would be surrounded by the family members. And behind the casket or the second line would typically be a brass band and members of the community who would walk behind the casket that was typically on a like mule-drawn carriage, and they, the brass band would start off playing fairly somber music, but very quickly would bring up this very jubilant, joyous music and the second line of all the community members and family would dance in the streets and they'd dance and they'd sing and laugh and just send their loved one off in joy, in beautiful memory. And that tradition has sort of grown into other areas of life. It's not just a funerary practice anymore. You can have second lines all the time, essentially.

 

SM:

Yeah, I've been I have I had one for the we went to the cocktail thing in June and they had one and it was great. I love the fact that you mentioned that you bookended them with this person. That's the way we should describe it.

 

But for food deserts, I do think we need to talk about it because, I've been to places in New Orleans very close even to the French quarter and they just have they don't have anything. And so, and particularly after Katrina and all of that.

 

Tell us just about the food deserts and in a way that's kind of the ending of the these because they don't even have market markets anymore. In supermarkets anymore. And describe that, but then we'll, we'll say at the end that Arthur Robinson was really the key.

 

ARY:

For sure. And so, when I was working at the Smithsonian, I really embraced the kind of value-driven work that we were doing there. The idea that historical work should be relevant to our contemporary moment. And so, as I was writing this book and thinking about my dissertation research, I kept thinking, but how can this help us understand what is going on today? And so, I felt like the book, especially adding in the chapters about the modern grocery store and white flight and the collapse of the public market system, it was all sort of leading to this understanding of how we ran into a food desert. This is the kind of common name that we use. Usually in urban places for communities that do not have easy access to affordable, safe, culturally appropriate foods. It's not that they don't necessarily have a grocery store in the vicinity, but it's either out of their reach economically or maybe isn't selling the kinds of foods that matter or make sense to their community. And so, you have an incredibly malnourished urban community. And Louisiana, unfortunately, has very high rates of malnourishment among children and adults. And so, I wanted this work, this book, to perhaps start getting at a potential solution or a different way of thinking about the history of markets. Is there a seed of truth or a seed of care and nutrient-dense food in this historic public market system in New Orleans. And I think there is. Food deserts, that's one term. Some academics now are using food apartheid to describe. . .

 

SM:

Yeah.

 

ARY:

. . . food deserts because these areas are so often populated by people of color and working poor that, businesses essentially cannot operate in those communities and turn a profit. So, they pull out of the communities and then those communities are left with just little corner stores or gas station, gas stations that might have some produce and milk. . .

 

SM:

Yeah.

 

ARY:

. . . but not really. And that some scholars argue that that loss of food access is intentional, and that city governments are not working with the communities to really find a solution that. . .

 

SM:

Okay.

 

ARY:

. . . is necessary for them. And I will say I've looked at the research of other scholars who've interviewed African American communities who might be within a food desert. And on the surface level, they might be saying, we need a grocery store, we want a grocery store. But really they're saying that because they know it will grab the attention of people. But really what community members are craving and desiring is greater equality and equity across the board, that they are treated with the same respect and given the same opportunities as other community members, that they have access to well-paying jobs, that they have access to solid public education, that it's a wellness or a way of life that is on par with other communities. That's what they're asking for. Parity. It's not just a grocery store. That's just the surface level. It's really about fixing larger, dare I say, structural issues in the country. And I make that point in the final chapter. And I encourage people to think about the public markets in New Orleans because each neighborhood, regardless of the ethnic makeup or racial makeup of that neighborhood, every neighborhood had a public market. And it was community members who worked in the market, it was community members who shopped there. So that economic system was constantly putting money back into the community, was reinforcing cultural ties. It was a very healthy system when not corrupted by the policies. . .

 

SM:

I had. . .

 

ARY:

. . . of the New Orleans government at that time. That's what I'm talking about when I think about food deserts and food apartheid.

 

SM:

And I think that's a great way to stop this conversation. And I would love everyone to go and get this, “Nourishing Networks: The Public Culture of Food in New Orleans.” Really wonderful book.

 

Now, we have some other fun questions that I've asked people who've been on this thing and it's usually hopefully it'll be fun.

 

Okay. If Ashley was a meal, what would it be?

 

ARY:

I've been thinking about this for a long time and I would definitely. . .

 

SM:

Ha ha ha ha.

 

ARY:

I would definitely be a soup or stew. And I think you could use any soup or stew, but I have to be corny and use gumbo. And the reason that I want to use gumbo is that it's a dish that is so shaped by history and has influences from throughout the world. And I feel like my own sort of family history and life history is one that's shaped by all of these different places. I also like that gumbo's a little spicy. And I feel like I have a little bit of a fight in me as well, or at least a zest or zeal for life, which. . .

 

SM:

That is.

 

ARY:

. . . I which I enjoy. And I will say too, it's really important for me to. . . like I feel like I inhabit the world where I want to build community. I love bringing people together and conversations or book clubs or board game nights or movie clubs. And I feel like gumbo is a dish where you're always saying, Hey, we have space for one more person at the table. Like just come on up, grab yourself a bowl, and let's chow down. So, I feel. . .

 

SM:

I love that. I. . .

 

ARY:

. . . as corny as it is that I'm a soup or stew, I'm gumbo.

 

SM:

That's it. That's perfect.

 

Okay. If Ashley had to go back in time to any meal at any time, where would it be?

 

ARY:

Ugh, this is such a great question. So, I lost my dear mother eight years ago, almost to this month, and I am constantly craving her food. Like not only do I miss her every day, but the food she was a phenomenal, phenomenal home cook. I would transport myself back in time to any family dinner that we had. Like I know that's a very personal answer, but man, I miss my mom.

 

SM:

But what no no, that's, that's a fine mum. But what I as. . . I miss my mum, I know about that. And she used to cook extraordinary food. She was a Welsh person who used to cook Indian food for my Indian father, which was very great. Anyway, you must do that, but you must name part of the dish.

 

ARY:

I know. So, my. . . not shocking that I identified myself as a soup or stew, but my mother made phenomenal soup. It was like my go-to comfort food. And she made just the best vegetable soup, but often with beef in it. That might it was actually my grandma Rosella's recipe. And my mom for years tried to recreate that soup, and she couldn't figure out what the spice was. There was something that always wasn't quite right. And my mom was, like I said, an excellent cook. She could re-re-create dishes easily from restaurants and things like that. But she finally figured out that the ingredient she was missing was pickling spice. My German grandmother used to add in like your basic McCormick pickling spice to her vegetable soup, beef vegetable soup. And to me, that is like chef's kiss. Best meal, I will have that any day.

 

SM:

I know that a lot of grandmothers and my grandmother, I think who the Welsh grandmother, she used to give the recipe to her daughter, or daughters in this case, but she always kept one bit back so that way people would come to her for that dish. And I know that. So maybe there was some other dishes as well. Okay.

 

ARY:

Yeah. Yes. In my. . . can I have a quick runner-up, which is at Commander's Palace in New Orleans, one of the most amazing bites that I ever had in my life was when I had their bread pudding souffle for the first time. And. . .

 

SM:

That I've had that.

 

ARY:

. . . it was like a Proustian moment. You know, it's like the. . .

 

SM:

Ha ha ha.

 

ARY:

. . . whole room, I felt like it shrunk. And every time I have it now, I'm just back in that very first moment where it has like it was just such a vibrant, amazing taste and I wanna go back to the first time I ever. . .

 

SM:

And the. . .

 

ARY:

. . . had it.

 

SM:

. . . Commander's Palace with those little bits. I know. That's a great place.

 

Okay. If Ashley had to go back in time to see the invention of everything, and it could be anything in the food world.

 

Anything.

 

ARY:

I'm thinking of Sour Patch Kids. They are my guilty pleasure. I always have them hiding somewhere in my house to my husband's dismay. And I wanna know, when the food scientist dreamed up the crazy, wonderful, sour world of Sour Patch Kids. I wanna know their. . .

 

SM:

Fantastic.

 

ARY:

. . . secret and what it was like.

 

SM:

Thank you for everything that you've done today.

 

ARY:

Yes. So, you can find me on Instagram at Ashley Rose Young. I'm also on X at the same handle and on Facebook as Ashley Rose Young. If you want to get in touch with me, please visit my website, AshleyRoseYoung.com. There's a contact form there and I would love to hear from you again if you're in DC and you want to look at some fabulous historic cookbooks together.

 

SM:

And I have to say I'm definitely gonna hold you up to that. So, thank you.

 

OUTRO MUSIC

 

SM:

Make sure to check out the website associated with this podcast at www.EatMyGlobe.com where we’ll be posting the transcripts from each episode, along with all the references and resources we used putting the episodes together, in case you want to delve deeper into each subject. There is also a contact button, so please do let us know if there are any subjects that you would like us to cover.

 

And, if you like what you hear, please don’t forget to join us on Patreon, subscribe, recommend us to your family and friends and give us a good rating on your favorite podcast provider.

 

Thank you and goodbye from me, Simon Majumdar, and we’ll speak to you soon on the next episode of EAT MY GLOBE: Things You Didn’t Know You Didn’t Know About Food.

 

CREDITS

The EAT MY GLOBE Podcast is a production of “It’s Not Much But It’s Ours” and “Producer Girl Productions.”

 

We would also like to thank Sybil Villanueva for all of her help both with the editing of the transcripts and her essential help with the research.

 

 

 

Publication Date: November 9, 2026

Apple Podcasts logo and "Listen on Apple Podcasts" and links to Eat My Globe on Apple Podcast
Spotify Logo and "Listen on Spotify" and links to Eat My Globe on Spotify
redhood-button-blue.png
iHeart Radio logo and "Listen on iHeart Radio" and links to Eat My Globe on iHeart Radio

Copy for your favorite podcast app:
https://eatmyglobe.libsyn.com/rss

  • Facebook Logo
  • Instagram Logo
  • Threads
  • Twitter Logo

© 2018-2026 by It's Not Much But It's Ours

bottom of page